Thursday, May 12, 2016

"You're killin' me, Nitrosomonas!", said Ammonia

Observations


  1. The GH number has restored to baseline, and KH remains at baseline.
  2. pH went up to 7.5 from 7.0
  3. Nitrites and Nitrates increased!
  4. Ammonia went down to 0.5 from 1.0 ppm.
  5. The plants are still not doing well. If I don't kill them through this process, I may have to reseed.

Analysis

I have to say that I'm happy with these numbers after being very concerned yesterday. I'm excited because it means that I'm on my way to introducing fish to the system. I'm hoping the number trends continue as the nitrosomonas eat the ammonia, which poop the nitrites, which are eaten by the nitrospira, which poop the nitrates, which are fed to the plants as a source of nitrogen and in turn clean the water and return it to the tank. Yes, poop is a technical term in the Nitrogen Cycle. :-) [please correct if wrong; I want to get it right]

As an aside, I previously read that nitrobacter were responsible for the nitrite to nitrate conversion, but I've since read that it's actually the nitrospira which perform this process; at least in the marine realm. There is actually a nice FAQ about cycling on The Aquaponics Source site that I just discovered. Its advice mirrors some of my own discovery.

Coming back to discussion of my system, my plants are not doing well. I understand that in order to get a balanced system, there's going to be a disruption first. My initial goal is to have water that will support the fish, so the plants will have to suffer until this is accomplished. Perhaps I should not have added the seeds right away, but I couldn't resist. I thought that it would be a good way to get the system online. I don't regret the decision though. The aforementioned FAQ actually recommends adding plants/seeds as soon as possible, so I guess that I was right in doing so.

Regarding the plants' health, I'm assuming that the change in the pH coincided with the health of the plants. I think there's still something to the theory I floated in a previous blog entry, but I'm not sure whether it's relevant to this situation.

In all, it's a bit of a breakthrough day for me and the system. The FAQ mentioned that I would be ready for fish if the ammonia and nitrite levels are at 0.5 ppm or lower. I'm now at the high end for both, but if the levels are okay, and if things don't change too much tomorrow, I'm going to buy some fish!

The Numbers


Date GH KH pH NO2 NO3 NH3/NH4 Temp °C
12-May 180 80 7.5 20 40 0.5 23°

The Nitrites Cometh!

Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Nitrites! Where art thou, nitrites?

Observations

  1. The General Hardness (GH) has dropped from 180 to 120 while the Carbonate Hardness (KH) has restored to its baseline number of 80. Could the flailing of the KH have been an harbinger for the change in the GH? I referenced this behavior yesterday regarding the KH and whether it was telling me something. Perhaps this was it?
  2. The other numbers are steady.
  3. The plants are not doing well. I can still smell them when my nose is about 6 inches from the growbed, but I no longer see any vibrant growth.
  4. No nitrites yet. What the hell? Sure, I could put in some tank starter stuff, but I'd rather not do so. I haven't put any pH UP into the tank in three days. I'm going to see how the water hardness plays out before doing more. It does bring me to some interesting observations overall; not just for the previous day.
The observations about the plants' health compared to the changing water conditions. The chive were growing very well at the beginning. They were the seeds to sprout and actually show progress. The basil and cilantro were the first to sprout, but I they really didn't go beyond the growth shown in the initial photos when this blog started.

When I started making changes to the pH in order to spurn the growth of the nitrites, the chives went downhill along with the other plants. Inversely, the peppers and thyme started to respond positively instead. Of course, none of them are responding well at present. The most significant changes that could have effected them were in the pH and water hardness. Also, the ammonia went up. I'm thinking that the increase was due to the water dechlorinator I used to replace evaporated water in the tank. When it performed its duty, it converted the chlorine into ammonia.

My theory, which I could probably Google to confirm somewhere (or debunk), are the differing water conditioning needed for different plants for optimum growth. Taking out the cold issue regarding the behavior of the chives, do peppers and thyme respond better to higher pH than chive, basil and cilantro? Originally, I thought that the shift in the pH level, in either direction, would cause shock to the plants, but others appeared to grow better. 

I know that I'm most likely not making any breakthrough statements here, but there are just my thoughts and observations about my system. Feel free to chime in if I'm making a total ass of myself. I want to stand corrected instead of being oblivious.

Tap Water Treatments

The tap water in my area comes through the Northern Kentucky Water District. From what I've read, they don't use chloramines to treat the water; just chlorine. So, I may be able to simply get away with filling a bucket full of water, and letting the chorine dissipate through sunlight and air. In the future, I'll refrain from the Top Fin stuff and use this method. Of course, I'm going to perform an ammonia test before and after to the bucket to confirm my findings regarding the Top Fin's releasing of ammonia.

The Numbers


Date GH KH pH NO2 NO3 NH3/NH4 Temp °C
11-May 120 80 7.0 0 20 1.0 24°


Tuesday, May 10, 2016

The numbers and little more

The Numbers


Date GH KH pH NO2 NO3 NH3/NH4 Temp °C
10-May 180 80 7.0 0 20 1.0 24°

Observations

  • The numbers are as mostly the same. I do think it's strange that the Carbonate Hardness (KH) is waffling back and forth. It's almost like it's telegraphing a catastrophe or just some kind of drastic change. Being the hobbyist that I am, I have no idea what this would be.
  • I'm going to think about what to do given my new knowledge from yesterday. Perhaps I'll do a 10-15% change per day with an alternate source of water that is not dechlorinated using Sodium Thiosulfate. We're not going to eat the fish from this system, but I think it's better to set the good practices now so that I can more easily apply them to a larger system later on.
  • All of the plants are wilting a bit. The pH changes may be playing a role. Hopefully, they will revive. I'm really inpatient to have suitable water for adding fish. I'll continue with readings and a strategy tomorrow.

Monday, May 9, 2016

Removing chloramines safely

The Issue

Earlier today, I expressed concern about the safety of the Tap Water Dechlorinator product that I was using to clear the chlorine and chloramines from the tap water that I put into my system. See the earlier post for details. To summarize, my main concern were:
  1. Is the product disrupting the cycling for aquaponics purposes? My tank has no nitrites but does have a level of nitrates. Is there something preventing those ammonia-eating bacteria from being formed?
  2. Is it safe to add such a product the water of a system from which we will eventually eat the plants?
  3. Is the product actually contributing to a spike in ammonia?
  4. What the hell is in this product? I can't find a site that has MSDS or any other clue as to what is in it?

Analysis and possible solution

After picking the algorithm of my personal librarian (Google), I discovered a couple of tidbits, such as:
  1. Most dechlorinator products are comprised of Sodium Thiosulfate (ST) and/or EDTA. The Sodium Thiosulfate handles the chlorine and chloramine , while the EDTA handles any heavy metals.
  2. I also read in a forum that the dechlorinator detoxifies nitrites and nitrates? There was no reference for this. I'm not sure if this point is relevant as long as these detoxified items do their part in the Nitrogen Cycle.
  3. A forum posting recounted the bad taste of fish in his system while he was using Sodium Thiosulfate as a dechlorinating agent. He mentioned that his fish tasted like sulfur. He stopped using it and it was highly reduced. I'm assuming that he replaced the fish and the water beforehand, but I'll try to find the link to prevent the spreading of bad information.
  4. The reaction of Sodium Thiosulfate winds up leaving ammonia after it does its job. This may explain one aspect of my water readings.
  5. I also read that there are rising concerns about the health effects of ST on humans and fish. However, there was no reference to any actual studies or articles about those concerns or what they comprised.
  6. Vitamin C appears to be the most natural source for removing chloromines from tap water. However, what is actually needed depends on how your municipal tap water is treated, as explained in the video below. Thanks, PhillyAquaponics!

So, will this will help solve the problem and lead to a healthier system? Do I have to perform a series of small water changes to reduce the effects of the dechlorinator product? Only time will tell.

Little change

The Numbers


Date GH KH pH NO2 NO3 NH3/NH4 Temp °C
9-May 180 120 7.0 0 20 1.0 24°

Observations

  • pH back to 7.0
  • KH back up but higher than baseline
  • Ammonia same as yesterday.
  • Nitrites and nitrates unchanged

Analysis

Thus far, the nitrates and nitrites have been pretty steady. I'm thinking that there are no nitrites to eat the bacteria and plants are not plentiful enough in the growbed to use all of the nitrates. I'm hoping that the better pH will help foster the creation of the Nitrosomonas needed for nitrite generation.

I have not applied pH UP to the tank today. Since it's so late in the day, I will will let it ride and check readings tomorrow.

A curious part of my analysis today, is that I tested my tap water for ammonia, but it turned out to be zero ppm (none). The other day, when I added dechlorinated water to the tank, my ammonia spiked the next day. I used Top Fin Water Dechlorinator to perform the conversion. The concerns are as follows:

  1. Is this product adding and/or converting chemicals in the water to ammonia?
  2. If this product is introducing ammonia into my system, will this product actually be detrimental in the long term; when fish are added to the tank. Since it's an aquaponics system, I really should not have to perform any water changes, but I will have to add water when enough of it has evaporated or used by the plants.
  3. I'm actually concerned about what is actually in this product. Is it going to be safe to use going forward? Top Fin doesn't appear to have a site to find this information.

Today's Chuckle

Found on Yahoo! Answers

How do I teach my fish to breathe outside the water?

He goes nuts when I take him out of his water. I don't underatand why he hates outside so much.

Sunday, May 8, 2016

More water, ammonia up

The Numbers


Date GH KH pH NO2 NO3 NH3/NH4 Temp °C
8-May 180 40 6.5 0 20 1.0 23°

Observations

  • Added about 1.5 gallons of dechlorinated water to the tank. It was too low. I used Top Fin Tap Water Dechlorinator. It's highly concentrated (1 mL/10 gallons), so just added a drop or two to a bucket of water, waited 15 minutes or so, when added it to the tank.
  • Added 21 drops of pH UP yesterday
  • Water temperature has been steady
  • The foam around the perimeter of the water's surface is almost gone.
  • More growth realized in the peppers.
  • pH reduced from 7.0 to 6.5
  • KH significantly dropped
  • Ammonia has significantly increased to 1.0 ppm.

Analysis

Today's growth
I'm a little worried about the ammonia spike since I only added dechlorinated water to the tank in addition to the pH UP drops. Hopefully, the spike in ammonia will also spike the bacteria which eats it.

After my readings today, I added 40 drops of pH UP (double the recommendation). There aren't any fish in the tank yet, but the young plants could be affected. It's safe to say that yesterday's addition of the water dropped the pH.

It's also strange that the KH also dropped significantly. This also correlates to the water addition. Of course, the effect could be a culmination of changes made over the previous several days.

I am done doing anything else to the tank for today. I'm still on the goal for a 7.5 pH to help jump-start the cycling. Once jump started, I'll let it reduce to 7.0 for a happy medium between plant and fish.

Saturday, May 7, 2016

pH UP: Day #2


The Numbers

Date GH KH pH NO2 NO3 NH3/NH4 Temp °C
7-May 180 80 7.0 0 20 0.5 24°

Observations

  • There continues to be a light foam wherever any object emerges from the water in the tank. This includes the growbed's intake hose, and tank perimeter. I thought it had dissipated, but it hasn't. However, it hasn't increased either.
  • Last night, I noticed the plants were wilting. The temperature of the tank and the room was fine. This morning, they're fine. The chives seem to be doing better as well.
  • The KH (carbonate hardness) spike from yesterday has returned to a normal level.
  • Other than the KH change and the tank temperature readings increasing by one degree, other values are unchanged.

Analysis

I don't have any insights other than that I have to give the tank more time for the desired changes to occur. In the interests of getting the beneficial bacteria to start working on the ammonia, I am going to put in another round of pH UP solution. I will do this daily until I either get a pH of 7.5 or I start seeing a spike in nitrites. We'll see what happens tomorrow.